I recommend “The Monster Show” by David J. Skal that touches on this covering the past 100 years.zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.
May the 4th 2020
-
- Charter Member
- Posts: 12057
- Joined: Sun May 21, 2017 11:06 am
Re: May the 4th 2020
Re: May the 4th 2020
i'll have to look for that.Headhunter wrote:I recommend “The Monster Show” by David J. Skal that touches on this covering the past 100 years.zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.
Re: May the 4th 2020
Obv.zombie wrote:do you like rocky 4?Jason wrote:Which movies?zombie wrote:i've seen plenty of recent movies that don't shove politics down my throat. there is an element of that, sure. but the 80s had a lot of politicking going in the movies, and we all love that decade. *shrug*Jason wrote:I enjoy when movies didn't shove politics down your throat. It's in video games too.

Re: May the 4th 2020
None of it is forced down your throat. Are you arguing it's not far more prominent today with an "in-your-face" approach?zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.

Re: May the 4th 2020
Horror, overall, is pretty good about not being political. But I guess when it comes down to it, you could find something political in everything.
And it's usually always leftism. :p
And it's usually always leftism. :p

-
- Charter Member
- Posts: 12057
- Joined: Sun May 21, 2017 11:06 am
Re: May the 4th 2020
I would say the biggest difference is you recognizing it. Perhaps you would have made similar arguments in past decades if you’d lived through them.Jason wrote:None of it is forced down your throat. Are you arguing it's not far more prominent today with an "in-your-face" approach?zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.
Re: May the 4th 2020
it was all over rocky 4. it was all over the exorcist. *shrug* i think we pick up on it and rebel against a certain kind of politics, more, because of the political climate lately, as a whole.Jason wrote:None of it is forced down your throat. Are you arguing it's not far more prominent today with an "in-your-face" approach?zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.
Re: May the 4th 2020
that too.Headhunter wrote:I would say the biggest difference is you recognizing it. Perhaps you would have made similar arguments in past decades if you’d lived through them.Jason wrote:None of it is forced down your throat. Are you arguing it's not far more prominent today with an "in-your-face" approach?zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.
Re: May the 4th 2020
I probably would have. But I am a huge Bond movie fan. I only lived through the last ten movies or so. They kind of maintain the same political climate and I haven't noticed anything very "in-your-face".Headhunter wrote:I would say the biggest difference is you recognizing it. Perhaps you would have made similar arguments in past decades if you’d lived through them.Jason wrote:None of it is forced down your throat. Are you arguing it's not far more prominent today with an "in-your-face" approach?zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.
On the other side, I watched along as Supernatural progressed. It started getting political around season 7 or so. Then after Trump's election it turned into a political shit show to appease the execs of CW...

Re: May the 4th 2020
you don't see the politics as negative or overt, because you're just enjoying the film. awesome. i have that same experience with a lot of film today.Jason wrote:Horror, overall, is pretty good about not being political. But I guess when it comes down to it, you could find something political in everything.
And it's usually always leftism. :p
Re: May the 4th 2020
I wouldn't say it was all over The Exorcist, by any stretch. Are you talking about the part where she's acting in that scene as an activist?zombie wrote:it was all over rocky 4. it was all over the exorcist. *shrug* i think we pick up on it and rebel against a certain kind of politics, more, because of the political climate lately, as a whole.Jason wrote:None of it is forced down your throat. Are you arguing it's not far more prominent today with an "in-your-face" approach?zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.

-
- Charter Member
- Posts: 12057
- Joined: Sun May 21, 2017 11:06 am
Re: May the 4th 2020
Outside of “wrap yourself in the flag” patriotism that was a hallmark of the 80s or rugged individualism that isn’t even really political, conservative ideals don’t translate well to film narrative the way liberal ideals do.Jason wrote:Horror, overall, is pretty good about not being political. But I guess when it comes down to it, you could find something political in everything.
And it's usually always leftism. :p
Re: May the 4th 2020
no. the church saved regan, when science couldn't.Jason wrote:I wouldn't say it was all over The Exorcist, by any stretch. Are you talking about the part where she's acting in that scene as an activist?zombie wrote:it was all over rocky 4. it was all over the exorcist. *shrug* i think we pick up on it and rebel against a certain kind of politics, more, because of the political climate lately, as a whole.Jason wrote:None of it is forced down your throat. Are you arguing it's not far more prominent today with an "in-your-face" approach?zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.
-
- Charter Member
- Posts: 12057
- Joined: Sun May 21, 2017 11:06 am
Re: May the 4th 2020
Like who wants to see a movie where the emotional crux is the tax rate being too high. Would never make sense.
Re: May the 4th 2020
People consider The Dark Knighjt trilogy to be considered Conservative.Headhunter wrote:Outside of “wrap yourself in the flag” patriotism that was a hallmark of the 80s or rugged individualism that isn’t even really political, conservative ideals don’t translate well to film narrative the way liberal ideals do.Jason wrote:Horror, overall, is pretty good about not being political. But I guess when it comes down to it, you could find something political in everything.
And it's usually always leftism. :p
The problem isn't conservatism translating into film, it's the fact that Hollywood is overrun with anti-conservative ideology.

Re: May the 4th 2020
Yeah, we'd all rather watch Jimmy cut his dick off, walk around in a dress and get handshakes from everyone for being brave.Headhunter wrote:Like who wants to see a movie where the emotional crux is the tax rate being too high. Would never make sense.

-
- Charter Member
- Posts: 12057
- Joined: Sun May 21, 2017 11:06 am
Re: May the 4th 2020
That’s a reach.Jason wrote:People consider The Dark Knighjt trilogy to be considered Conservative.Headhunter wrote:Outside of “wrap yourself in the flag” patriotism that was a hallmark of the 80s or rugged individualism that isn’t even really political, conservative ideals don’t translate well to film narrative the way liberal ideals do.Jason wrote:Horror, overall, is pretty good about not being political. But I guess when it comes down to it, you could find something political in everything.
And it's usually always leftism. :p
The problem isn't conservatism translating into film, it's the fact that Hollywood is overrun with anti-conservative ideology.
It always has been.
-
- Charter Member
- Posts: 12057
- Joined: Sun May 21, 2017 11:06 am
Re: May the 4th 2020
What movie is that from?Jason wrote:Yeah, we'd all rather watch Jimmy cut his dick off, walk around in a dress and get handshakes from everyone for being brave.Headhunter wrote:Like who wants to see a movie where the emotional crux is the tax rate being too high. Would never make sense.
Re: May the 4th 2020
That isn't political more so than religion vs science. There are tons of deeply religious liberals. That's a different scenario.zombie wrote:no. the church saved regan, when science couldn't.Jason wrote:I wouldn't say it was all over The Exorcist, by any stretch. Are you talking about the part where she's acting in that scene as an activist?zombie wrote:it was all over rocky 4. it was all over the exorcist. *shrug* i think we pick up on it and rebel against a certain kind of politics, more, because of the political climate lately, as a whole.Jason wrote:None of it is forced down your throat. Are you arguing it's not far more prominent today with an "in-your-face" approach?zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.

Re: May the 4th 2020
you're the one that's making a distinction between political ideologies. i didn't say it wasn't liberal.Jason wrote:That isn't political more so than religion vs science. There are tons of deeply religious liberals. That's a different scenario.zombie wrote:no. the church saved regan, when science couldn't.Jason wrote:I wouldn't say it was all over The Exorcist, by any stretch. Are you talking about the part where she's acting in that scene as an activist?zombie wrote:it was all over rocky 4. it was all over the exorcist. *shrug* i think we pick up on it and rebel against a certain kind of politics, more, because of the political climate lately, as a whole.Jason wrote:None of it is forced down your throat. Are you arguing it's not far more prominent today with an "in-your-face" approach?zombie wrote:this whole discussion is pretty goofy to be had among horror fans... it's always had an element of political or social commentary, as far back as you want to go.